| | The intervention with the strongest evidence | | Combined resistance and weight-bearing exercise | | Meta-analysis of 84 exercise groups |
| | A 2020 meta-analysis (Kemmler et al.) pooled 84 exercise groups from controlled trials in postmenopausal women. Combined weight-bearing and resistance training showed the largest effect at the lumbar spine (SMD 0.42, 95% CI 0.23 to 0.61). The effect was real but small in absolute terms. A 2023 network meta-analysis found moderate-intensity resistance training three days per week was clinically preferred for BMD at the spine and hip. | | | | “All types of exercise significantly affect BMD at the lumbar spine, femoral neck, and total hip. Combined weight-bearing and resistance training showed the largest effect at the spine.” | | Kemmler et al., Calcified Tissue International, 2020 |
|
| | What it is not | | The effect sizes are small. Exercise is one component of bone health, not a sole intervention for someone already at high fracture risk. |
|
| | When to call | | You are postmenopausal and have never had a DXA scan. The USPSTF (2025) recommends screening for all women 65 and older, and for postmenopausal women under 65 with risk factors including low body weight, parental hip fracture, smoking, or excess alcohol. | | | | You have lost 1.5 inches or more from your peak adult height. The BHOF Clinician's Guide recommends vertebral imaging at this threshold. | | | | You fractured a bone from a fall at standing height or less. A low-impact fracture warrants a bone density assessment. |
|
| | This week | | Measure your height against a wall. If you know your height at 20 or 25, compare. This is the simplest record of a change that gives no other warning. | | Three days this week, do a set of squats, step-ups, and rows using household weight. Moderate intensity means the last two repetitions feel hard. This is the type of loading the meta-analyses associate with preserved BMD. | | Check whether you are due for screening. If you are postmenopausal and under 65, look at the risk factors above. Bring the height measurement from step one. |
| | Bone responds to mechanical strain by increasing formation at the sites where force is applied. Women who did this type of exercise in trials lost less bone than women who did not. The effect is real and modest. Start with what you have. | | One tap, no form | | Have you thought about your bones? | | Tap to reply. Nothing is shared. | | | | | | Or write in your own words. Every reply is read. |
| | | | Every source read for this issue | | One longitudinal cohort, two meta-analyses, one clinical guideline, and one screening recommendation. | | 1 | Faster LS Bone Loss Predicts Fracture Shieh et al., JCEM, 2021 (SWAN) | | | | 2 | Exercise and BMD in Postmenopausal Women Kemmler et al., Calcif Tissue Int, meta-analysis, 2020 | | | | 3 | Resistance Training and BMD Wang et al., Front Physiol, network meta-analysis, 2023 | | | | 4 | Prevention and Treatment of Osteoporosis LeBoff et al., Osteoporos Int, guideline (BHOF), 2022 | | | | 5 | Screening for Osteoporosis to Prevent Fractures USPSTF, JAMA, 2025 |
|
|
|